China Coast Guard patrol cutter CCG 3104 collided with People's Liberation Army Navy (PLAN) Type 052D Destroyer (164, Guilin) while pursuing Philippines Coast Guard vessel BRP Suluan in the South China Sea

China Coast Guard patrol cutter CCG 3104 collided with People's Liberation Army Navy (PLAN) Type 052D Destroyer (164, Guilin) while pursuing Philippines Coast Guard vessel BRP Suluan in the South China Sea. Image from video

China, Philippines Trade Blame Over Collision in Contested Sea

Bloomberg
Total Views: 1433
August 15, 2025

By Bloomberg News

Aug 15, 2025 (Bloomberg) –China and the Philippines are trading blame over an incident earlier this week in which two Chinese ships collided in the South China Sea, where both nations have competing territorial claims.

On Monday, a China Coast Guard vessel had its bow badly damaged in a collision with a People’s Liberation Army Navy ship. 

Manila has said the incident occurred as the vessels were chasing a Philippine Coast Guard ship, but Chinese Ministry of National Defense spokesperson Jiang Bin on Friday accused Philippine ships of having engaged in “dangerous maneuvers,” such as high-speed ramming and large-angle turns across the bows of Chinese vessels.

This “created a complex and urgent situation at sea, seriously infringed upon China’s sovereignty and rights, seriously endangered the safety of Chinese vessels and personnel, and seriously undermined peace and stability in the South China Sea,” Jiang added.

Manila denies those allegations. 

The Philippines “bears no responsibility for the collision between the PLAN vessel and the CCG vessel,” Foreign Affairs Secretary Ma. Theresa Lazaro said in a statement released by the Presidential Communications Office. “It was an unfortunate outcome, but not one caused by our actions.” 

Beijing’s claims to parts of the South China Sea — which are widely contested — have led to multiple maritime incidents involving the Philippines, and the Chinese navy earlier this week said it expelled a US Navy ship from the area. The US Navy rejected that characterization, describing the operation as a lawful assertion of navigational rights. 

Read More:  China, US Clash Over Naval Incident Near Scarborough Shoal

In referring to Monday’s events, the China Coast Guard said in a statement that it warned off a fleet of Philippine boats after the latter deliberately intruded into the waters near Scarborough Shoal despite repeated warnings. It didn’t mention Chinese ships colliding. 

Instead it said it took “necessary measures, including monitoring, forcing, intercepting and controlling the Philippine vessels to expel them.” 

© 2025 Bloomberg L.P.

Back to Main